Benny Abbott and Joy Moore host one of the most beloved podcasts in the world. Each week, they delight listeners with a different “against all odds” survival story, gleefully finding the weird, life-affirming humor in near-death experiences. Since their first episode on Joy’s experience with severe narcolepsy, they’ve been the best friends everyone wants to befriend—and thanks to the meticulous management of Joy’s husband, Xander, they’ve built a lucrative empire.

The problem is, their next survival story may be their own. When Benny arrives at Joy and Xander’s one morning to record, he finds shattered glass and an empty house. The one clue shedding light on the couple’s disappearance is the incomplete, previously unseen first draft of Joy’s memoir. Benny will stop at nothing to find them, even as the police zero in on him as their prime suspect.

Millions of devoted listeners think they know the “real” Benny and Joy. But as the hours tick by, and the odds seem increasingly stacked against Joy and Xander being found alive, not even the most devoted fans could guess the terrible secrets their favorite famous BFFs have hidden from the world—and from each other.

I really enjoyed this book. The characters were air tight and completely relatable, and the mystery kept me hooked from start to finish.

Benny and Joy are best friends who host a wildly popular podcast. Every week, they tell survival stories about people who beat the odds and lived to tell about it. They find this weird, life-affirming humor in near-death experiences, and their listeners love them for it. They’ve built a whole empire around this podcast, thanks largely to the business savvy of Joy’s husband, Xander.

But one morning, Benny shows up at Joy and Xander’s house to record and finds shattered glass and nobody home. Joy and Xander are gone. The only clue left behind is an incomplete first draft of Joy’s memoir that Benny has never seen before. He’s determined to find them, but the police have other ideas. They think Benny might have something to do with their disappearance.

The format of this book works really well. We hear from Benny in the present as he’s searching for Joy and Xander and trying to clear his name. And we hear from Joy in the past through her unfinished memoir. This structure gives us the full picture without revealing everything too soon. You’re constantly piecing things together, and just when you think you know where it’s going, you get another piece of information that shifts your perspective.

The podcast angle also adds a layer of meta-commentary about parasocial relationships. Millions of people think they know the real Benny and Joy. They listen every week, and they feel connected to them. But the truth is, nobody really knows them. Not even their most devoted fans. And honestly, Benny and Joy don’t even fully know each other and this is another thing that’s explored in the book.

My friend and I started a podcast during the pandemic just to pass the time, and some of the conversations Benny and Joy have made me think of us. The dynamic between them felt real. The inside jokes. The way they finish each other’s sentences. The comfort of having someone who just gets you all rang true.

Benny and Joy are fantastic characters. They’re not perfect, but they’re genuinely likable. You root for them and you want them to be okay. And as the story unfolds and you start to learn what they’ve been hiding, you understand them even more.

The mystery of what happened to Joy and Xander is solid. It’s not overly complicated, and it was totally logical. I enjoyed trying to figure out where they went and why, and I loved discovering what really happened piece by piece. The pacing is perfect. The reveals all came at the right time. Nothing felt rushed and nothing dragged. There were no unbelievable moments where I had to suspend disbelief or roll my eyes. Everything made sense within the world Crum created.

What I appreciated most is how the book handles secrets. Everyone in this story is hiding something. Not necessarily because they’re bad people, but because life is complicated and messy and sometimes we don’t know how to be honest about the hard stuff. Watching those secrets come to light and seeing how they’ve shaped these characters and their relationships was compelling.

This is a book about friendship, secrets, survival, and what happens when the life you’ve built starts to crumble. It’s engaging, it’s well-paced, and the characters are people you’ll care about.

If you’re a fan of mysteries with strong character work, or stories about complicated friendships and the secrets people keep, pick this up. Great characters. Solid mystery. Engaging story. Highly recommended.

Book Club/Book Box: